I’ve always hated BCA tables. As such, I’ve never used them so don’t need to ‘kick them to the curb’, but you should. I’ve hated them mostly because it’s just another one of those things that in my eyes is an unnecessary crutch, that some teachers want to use because either they (or their students) simply couldn’t handle stoichiometry in its purest form. These people are often part of the modeling crowd. All of that fits with my opinion that that chemistry should most definitely not be taught to all students, even at its most basic level.
My feelings about the larger question of everyone being in chemistry classes aside, I recently happily came across what I consider to be a really tangible reason to eschew BCA tables. Many of you will be familiar with the furore 2016, 6(a) caused in the AP Chemistry community, with many AP chemistry teachers failing to understand the problem. Now, it may be that the fuss caused among many teachers said more about their abilities than the question itself, and for what it’s worth I thought it was a fine question. Either way I wrote about it here back in 2016.
This question is a favorite of mine when it comes to tutoring and teaching equilibrium, and recently I had a student get the answer to part (a) correct, but I was suspicious. I wasn’t convinced that they actually knew how to do the problem, so I dug a little deeper. It turned out that they had not considered the K value at all, and had “incorrectly” applied a BCA calculation in lieu of an ICE table! In short, they thought that they were doing an ICE table, but had brought their BCA knowledge to the party. Now of course this does yield the correct answer in this case, BUT in just about all other ICE situations it’s going to be completely wrong. BCA had clouded their ICE knowledge.
Finally, I’d found a tangible reason for me to hate on BCA. That made me happy.












0 Comments