MEL – a brief follow-up

December 28, 2015
Categories: Labs | Reviews

Following my review of the MEL Chemistry Kits, I was contacted by MEL CEO Vassili Philippov (@vassiliph) to thank me for the feedback.

When you read my original review, you’ll see that although I was generally very impressed with the kits themselves, I was less thrilled with some of the simplicity of the chemistry ‘experiments’ that came with them. Vassili was receptive to the feedback and made a really great point, that I thought worth repeating here, since it gives some context to my critique.

As I had anticipated, Vassili told me that there are all kinds of restrictions on chemicals that can be supplied with such kits, but when one takes a close look at the list, as he says, it’s quite a challenge to come up with interesting experiments that can be done with them!

EN 71-4

In the European Union, the chemicals that are allowed chemistry sets like MEL’s are governed by the European Standard EN 71-4, the safety requirements for toys, more specifically, for Experimental sets for chemistry and related activities. The list is very restrictive (about 60 substances), and includes limits on the amounts of the chemicals that are allowed. The complete list can be viewed here. When one considers that list, and the shackles that it imposes, it gives a lot more context to my criticisms.

 

2 Comments

  1. Karl Jenkiins

    And yet another reason the EU must (and will) be disbanded.

    Reply
    • Dave

      Yes, Karl, please let us be able to delivery litres of hydrochloric acid to our young kids in boxes marked “completely child safe”. This is another reason the EU will (and must) continue. Any parent who actually knows their stuff, and therefore might be considered safe to supervise their children, is able to acquire and create more complex experiments.

      Reply

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. MEL Science Reviewed - Adrian Dingle's Chemistry Pages - […] Please read this brief, follow-up post for more […]

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

HONORS MATERIALS

REGULAR MATERIALS

ORGANIC COURSE 2

ADRIAN'S CHEMISTRY BOOKS

Check out all of my books

CHEMISTRY BOOK GALLERIES

Pretty pictures of my books

CHEMISTRY WRITING PORTFOLIO

Chemistry writing beyond books

PAYPAL
QUICKPAY

Send any $ amount via PayPal Quick Pay

CREDIT CARDS
VIA STRIPE

Send any $ amount with Visa, MC, Amex etc.

VENMO
TRANSFER

Send any $ amount via Venmo transfer

SUBMIT A
SCHOOL PO

Pay via an invoice and a school purchase order